skip to navigation
skip to content

sos-vcs 2018.1103.3029

Subversion Offline Solution (SOS)

Latest Version: 2018.1111.2555

List of Abbreviations and Definitions

Introduction

If you (love, or simply have to) work with the SVN VCS, but need (or lack) the flexibility of committing and branching files offline (without a permanent network connection) similar to how Git is able to, SOS is your straight-forward and super simple command-line SCM solution:

SOS allows performing offline operations a) as a drop-in replacement for svn and other VCS commands, b) as an offline extension of those VCSs that either don’t support offline branching and committing or are too complex, and c) as a standalone VCS. You may run sos offline not only inside a SVN checkout, but in any (and also multiple, even nested) folders of your file system, even outside of VCS repository checkouts/clones.

SOS thus augments SVN with offline operation and serves the same need as RCS, CVS, Git, gitless, Bazaar, Mercurial, and Fossil.

As an additional practical benefit, the sos command will double as the command line interface of any popular VCS and will execute any svn, git, etc. command by sos <command> [<arguments-and-options>], e.g. sos commit -m "Message" instead of svn commit -m "Message" or git commit -m "Message". Once you executed sos offline, however, all commands are interpreted by the SOS tool instead, until leaving the offline mode via sos online (with the exception of sos config, cf. details below).

Flexible VCS Modes

SOS supports three different file handling models that you may use to your liking, thus being able to mimick different traditional VCSs, plus a new mode for super quick and easy version management (the default). - Simple mode: All files are automatically versioned and tracked. Drawback: Will pickup any little modification for any file, binary or not - Tracking mode: Only files that match certain file patterns are respected during commit, update and branch (just like in SVN, gitless, and Fossil), requiring users to specifically add or remove files per branch. Drawback: Need to declare files to track for every offline repository - Picky mode: Each operation needs the explicit declaration of file patterns for versioning (like Git does). Drawback: Need to stage files for every single commit

Unique Features of SOS

  • Initializes repositories by default with the simple mode, which makes effortless versioning a piece of cake
  • In the optional tracking mode, files are tracked via file patterns instead of pure filenames or paths (in a manner comparable to how SVN ignores files)
  • Command line replacement for traditional VCS that transparently pipes commands to them
  • Straightforward and simplified semantics for common VCS operations (branch, commit, integrate changes)

Limitations

  • Designed for use by single user, network synchronization is a non-goal. Don’t attempt to use SOS in a shared location, concurrent access to the repository may corrupt your data, as there is currently no locking in place (could be augmented, but it’s a non-goal too)
  • Has a small user base as of now, therefore no reliable reports of compatibility and operational capability except for the automatic unit tests run on Travis CI and AppVeyor

Compatibility

  • SOS runs on any Python 3 distribution, including some versions of PyPy. Python 2 is not fully supported yet due to library issues, although SOS’s programming language Coconut is generally able to transpile to valid Python 2 source code
  • SOS is compatible with above mentioned traditional VCSs: SVN, Git, gitless, Bazaar, Mercurial and Fossil
  • Filename encoding and console encoding: Full roundtrip support (on Windows) started only with Python 3.6.4 and has not been tested nor confirmed yet for SOS

Latest Changes

  • Version 1.1 released on 2017-12-30:
    • Bug 90 Removed directories weren’t picked up
    • Bug 93 Picky mode lists any file as added
    • Enhancement 63 Show more change details in log and status, and also ls (in #101)
    • Enhancement 86 Renamed command for branch removal to destroy
    • Feature 8 Added functionality to rename tracking patterns and move files accordingly
    • Feature 61 Added option to only consider or exclude certain file patterns for relevant operations using --only and --except. Note: These have to be already tracked file patterns, currently, see #99 and #100
    • Feature 80 Added functionality to use tags
    • QA 79 Added AppVeyor automated testing
    • QA 94 More test coverage
    • Many little fixes and improvements
  • Version 1.0 released on 2017-12-14:
    • First release with basic functionality
    • Lots of test cases, good test coverage
    • System integration and packaging
    • Library integration and testing
    • VCS integration

Comparison with Traditional VCSs

While completing version 1.0 of SOS, I incidentally discovered an interesting article by Gregory Szorc that discusses central weaknesses in the design of popular VCSs, with a focus on Git. Many of his arguments I have intuitively felt to be true as well and were the reason for the development of SOS: mainly the reduction of barriers between the developer’s typical workflow and the VCS, which is most often used as a structured tool for “type and save in increments”, while advanced features of Git are just very difficult to remember and get done right.

  • While Git is basically a large key-value store with a thin access interface on top, SOS keeps a very clear (folder) structure of branches, revisions and files
  • Compared to SVN SOS’s file store is much simpler and doesn’t require an integrated database
  • The term file tree is used thoughout this document to refer to the actual state of files and folders on the user’s computer at a certain point in time. It’s not exactly the same as a checkout or working copy, but largely comparable.

Here is a comparison between SOS and VCS’s commands: - branch creates a branch from the current file tree (or last commit), but also switches to it immediately (unless told not to). There is no requirement to name branches, removing all barriers - SOS allows to branch from the latest committed revision via sos branch [<name>] --last; this automatically applies when in tracking and picky mode. In consequence any changes performed since last commit will automatically be considered as a change for the next commit on the branch unless --stay was added as well to not switch to the new branch - commit creates a numbered revision similar to SVN, but revision numbers are only unique per branch, as they aren’t stored in a global namespace. The commit message is optional on purpose (since sos commit serves largely as a CTRL+S replacement) - The first revision (created during execution of sos offline or sos branch) always has the number 0 - Each sos commit increments the revision number by one; revisions are referenced by this numeric index only - delete destroys and removes a branch. It’s a command, not an option flag as in git branch -d <name> - move renames a file tracking pattern and all matching files accordingly; only useful in tracking or picky mode. It supports reordering of literal substrings, but no reordering of glob markers (*, ? etc.), and no adjacent glob markers. Use --soft to avoid files actually being renamed in the file tree. Warning: the --force option flag will be considered for several consecutive, potentially dangerous operations. TODO allow and consider --force several times on the command line - switch works like checkout in Git for a revision of another branch (or of the current), or update to latest or a specific revision in SVN. Please note that switching to a different revision will in no way fix or remember that revision. The file tree will always be compared to the branch’s latest commit for change detection - update works a bit like pull in Git or update in SVN and replays the given branch’s and/or revision’s changes into the file tree. There are plenty of options to configure what changes are actually integrated. This command will not switch the current branch like switch does. Note, that this is not a real 3-way merge, just an enhanced diff logic.

When differing contents are to be merged, there is always a potential for conflict; not all changes can be merged automatically with confidence. SOS takes a simplistic and pragmatic approach and largely follows a simple diff algorithm to detect and highlight changes. Insertions and deletions are noted, and modifications are partially detected and marked as such. There are different layers of changes that SOS is able to work on:
- File addition or removal in the file tree, e.g. when updating from another branch and/or revision or switching to them
- Line insertion or deletion inside a file, e.g. when merging file modifications during update
- Character insertion or deletion on a text line, e.g. when non-conflicting intra-line differences are detected
- Updating state from another branch in the `--track` or `--picky` mode will always combine all tracked file patterns. To revert this, use the `switch --meta` command to pull back in another branch's and/or revision's tracking patterns to the currently active branch
- There may be, however, blocks of text lines that seem inserted/deleted but may have actually just been moved inside the file. SOS attempts to detect clear cases of moved blocks and silently accepts them no matter what. TODO implement and introduce option flag to avoid this behavior

Working in Track and Picky Modes

Use the commands sos add <pattern> or sos rm <pattern> to add or remove file patterns. These patterns always refer to a specific (relative) file path and may contain globbing characters ?*[!] only in the filename part of the path.

Configuration Options

These options can be set or unset by the user and apply globally for all offline operations the user performs from that moment on. Some of these options can be set on a per-repository basis during creation (e.g. sos offline --track --strict), others can only be set in a persistant fashion (e.g. sos config set texttype "*.xsd").

Configuration Commands

  • sos config set sets a boolean flag, a string, or an initial list (semicolon-separated)
  • sos config unset removes a setting
  • sos config add adds a string entry to a list
  • sos config rm removes a string entry from a list
  • sos config show lists all defined configuration settings

User Configuration and Defaults

SOS optionally uses the `configr <https://github.com/ArneBachmann/configr>`__ library to manage per-user global defaults, e.g. for the --strict and --track flags that the offline command takes, but also for file and folder exclusion patterns. By means of the sos config set <key> <value> command, you can set these flags flag with values like 1, no, on, false, enable or disabled.

Available Configuration Settings

  • strict: Flag for always performing full file comparsion, not relying on file size and modification timestamp only. Default: False
  • track: Flag for always going offline in tracking mode (SVN-style). Default: False
  • picky: Flag for always going offline in picky mode (Git-styly). Default: False
  • compress: Flag for compressing versioned artifacts. Default: True
  • defaultbranch: Name of the initial branch created when going offline. Default: Dynamic per type of VCS in current working directory (e.g. master for Git, trunk for SVN)
  • texttype: List of file patterns that should be recognized as text files that can be merged through textual diff, in addition to what Python’s mimetypes library will detect as a text/... mime. Default: Empty list
  • bintype: List of file patterns that should be recognized as binary files that cannot be merged textually, overriding potential matches in texttype. Default: Empty list
  • ignores: List of filename patterns (without folder path) to ignore during repository operations. Any match from the corresponding white list will negate any hit for ignores
  • ignoresWhitelist: List of filename patterns to be consider even if matched by an entry in the ignores list
  • ignoreDirs: As ignores, but for folder names
  • ignoreDirsWhitelist: As ignoresWhitelist, but for folder names

Noteworthy Details

  • SOS doesn’t store branching point information (or references); each branch stands alone and has no relation whatsoever to other branches or certain revisions thereof, except incidentally its initial file contents
  • File tracking patterns are stored per branch, but not versioned with commits. This means that the “what to track” metadata is not part of the changesets.
  • sos update will not warn if local changes are present! This is a noteworthy exception to the failsafe approach taken for most other commands

FAQ

Q: I don’t want to risk data loss in case SOS has some undiscovered bugs. What can I do?

A: Configure SOS to store all versioned files as plain file copies instead of compressed artifacts: sos offline --plain for one repository only, or sos config set compress off to define a user-preset before going offline. Plain repositories simply copy files when branching and/or versioning; note, however, that filenames will be hashed and stored in the metadata file instead (which is human-readable, thankfully).

Hints and Tipps

  • Too speed up going offline, use the sos offline --plain option: It may reduce the time for going offline by a larger factor (in tests on a small laptop with BTRFS it was 30 times faster due to avoiding Python having to compress all versioned file contents)
  • When specifying file patterns including glob markers on the command line, make sure you quote them correctly. On linux (bash, sh, zsh), put your patterns into quote ("), otherwise the shell will replace file patterns by any matching filenames instead of forwarding the pattern literally to SOS
  • Many commands can be shortened to three, two or even one initial letters
  • It might in some cases be a good idea to go offline one folder higher up in the file tree than your base working folder to care for potential deletions or renames
  • dirty flag only relevant in track and picky mode (?) TODO investigate - is this true, and if yes, why
  • Branching larger amounts of binary files may be expensive as all files are copied and/or compressed during sos offline. A workaround is to sos offline only in the folders that are relevant for a specific task

Development and Contribution

See CONTRIBUTING.md for information.

Release Management

  • Increase version number in setup.py
  • Run python3 setup.py clean build test sdist to update the PyPI version number, compile and test the code, and package it into an archive. If you need evelated rights to do so, use sudo -E python....
  • Run git add, git commit and git push and let Travis CI and AppVeyor run the tests against different target platforms. If there were no problems, continue:
  • Run twine upload dist/*.tar.gz to upload the previously created distribution archive to PyPI.
 
File Type Py Version Uploaded on Size
sos-vcs-2018.1103.3029.tar.gz (md5) Source 2018-01-03 109KB